{"generated_at":"2026-11-19T02:06:36+00:00","scoring":"deferred","people":[{"id":"LA-CARROLL","slug":"ben-carroll","name":"Ben Carroll","party":"Australian Labor Party","chamber":"Legislative Assembly","electorate":"Niddrie","jurisdiction":"Victoria","profile_url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/members/ben-carroll/","snapshot_date":"2026-11-18","electoral_status":"Outgoing 60th Parliament member; 2026 candidacy separately checked at pilot cutoff","published":1,"watched":1,"last_checked":"2026-11-19T01:56:15+00:00","next_check":"2026-11-20T01:56:15+00:00","coverage":{"votes":{"complete":false,"note":"Pilot division sample only. Full historical backfill and eligibility reconciliation are outstanding."},"career":{"complete":false,"note":"Dated parliamentary profile roles and attributed prior employment; unknown dates remain unknown."},"interests":{"period":"1 February–30 June 2026","complete":false},"donations":{"complete":false,"note":"Not reconciled"},"research_cutoff":"2026-11-18"},"summary":"The evidence supports several concrete actions by Carroll: commissioning a VCAA review, announcing safeguards after the 2024 exam problems, and introducing an IBAC reform bill that subsequently received assent. It does not establish that every exam result was fair, that all reforms were implemented, or that his teacher workforce claims were accurate. A separate IBAC investigation expressly excludes him from adverse comment. These distinctions matter more than a general judgment about his character.","owner_accepted":true},{"id":"LA-WILSON","slug":"jess-wilson","name":"Jess Wilson","party":"Liberal Party","chamber":"Legislative Assembly","electorate":"Kew","jurisdiction":"Victoria","profile_url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/members/jess-wilson/","snapshot_date":"2026-11-18","electoral_status":"Outgoing 60th Parliament member; 2026 candidacy separately checked at pilot cutoff","published":1,"watched":1,"last_checked":"2026-11-19T01:56:46+00:00","next_check":"2026-11-20T01:56:46+00:00","coverage":{"votes":{"complete":false,"note":"Pilot division sample only. Full historical backfill and eligibility reconciliation are outstanding."},"career":{"complete":false,"note":"Dated parliamentary profile roles and attributed prior employment; unknown dates remain unknown."},"interests":{"period":"1 February–30 June 2026","complete":false},"donations":{"complete":false,"note":"Not reconciled"},"research_cutoff":"2026-11-18"},"summary":"Wilson's recorded questions expose claims that can be checked individually: projected teacher shortages, school vacancies and the cost and effect of an infrastructure levy. The pilot verifies that she made those claims and adds primary context for the levy. It does not settle the workforce figures or establish deliberate deception. A named division also supplies evidence of an individual parliamentary action.","owner_accepted":true},{"id":"LA-SANDELL","slug":"ellen-sandell","name":"Ellen Sandell","party":"The Australian Greens - Victoria","chamber":"Legislative Assembly","electorate":"Melbourne","jurisdiction":"Victoria","profile_url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/members/ellen-sandell/","snapshot_date":"2026-11-18","electoral_status":"Outgoing 60th Parliament member; 2026 candidacy separately checked at pilot cutoff","published":0,"watched":1,"last_checked":"2026-11-19T01:57:18+00:00","next_check":"2026-11-20T01:57:18+00:00","coverage":{"votes":{"complete":false,"note":"Pilot division sample only. Full historical backfill and eligibility reconciliation are outstanding."},"career":{"complete":false,"note":"Dated parliamentary profile roles and attributed prior employment; unknown dates remain unknown."},"interests":{"period":"1 February–30 June 2026","complete":false},"donations":{"complete":false,"note":"Not reconciled"},"research_cutoff":"2026-11-18"},"summary":"Identity checked against the pilot sources. The corrected dossier awaits owner review.","owner_accepted":false},{"id":"LA-MCCURDY","slug":"tim-mccurdy","name":"Tim McCurdy","party":"The Nationals","chamber":"Legislative Assembly","electorate":"Ovens Valley","jurisdiction":"Victoria","profile_url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/members/tim-mccurdy/","snapshot_date":"2026-11-18","electoral_status":"Outgoing 60th Parliament member; 2026 candidacy separately checked at pilot cutoff","published":0,"watched":1,"last_checked":"2026-11-19T01:57:54+00:00","next_check":"2026-11-20T01:57:54+00:00","coverage":{"votes":{"complete":false,"note":"Pilot division sample only. Full historical backfill and eligibility reconciliation are outstanding."},"career":{"complete":false,"note":"Dated parliamentary profile roles and attributed prior employment; unknown dates remain unknown."},"interests":{"period":"1 February–30 June 2026","complete":false},"donations":{"complete":false,"note":"Not reconciled"},"research_cutoff":"2026-11-18"},"summary":"Identity checked against the pilot sources. The corrected dossier awaits owner review.","owner_accepted":false},{"id":"LC-SYMES","slug":"jaclyn-symes","name":"Jaclyn Symes","party":"Australian Labor Party","chamber":"Legislative Council","electorate":"Northern Victoria","jurisdiction":"Victoria","profile_url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/members/jaclyn-symes/","snapshot_date":"2026-11-18","electoral_status":"Outgoing 60th Parliament member; 2026 candidacy separately checked at pilot cutoff","published":0,"watched":1,"last_checked":"2026-11-19T01:59:15+00:00","next_check":"2026-11-20T01:59:15+00:00","coverage":{"votes":{"complete":false,"note":"Pilot division sample only. Full historical backfill and eligibility reconciliation are outstanding."},"career":{"complete":false,"note":"Dated parliamentary profile roles and attributed prior employment; unknown dates remain unknown."},"interests":{"period":"1 February–30 June 2026","complete":false},"donations":{"complete":false,"note":"Not reconciled"},"research_cutoff":"2026-11-18"},"summary":"Identity checked against the pilot sources. The corrected dossier awaits owner review.","owner_accepted":false},{"id":"LC-CROZIER","slug":"georgie-crozier","name":"Georgie Crozier","party":"Liberal Party","chamber":"Legislative Council","electorate":"Southern Metropolitan","jurisdiction":"Victoria","profile_url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/members/georgie-crozier/","snapshot_date":"2026-11-18","electoral_status":"Outgoing 60th Parliament member; 2026 candidacy separately checked at pilot cutoff","published":0,"watched":1,"last_checked":"2026-11-19T01:59:51+00:00","next_check":"2026-11-20T01:59:51+00:00","coverage":{"votes":{"complete":false,"note":"Pilot division sample only. Full historical backfill and eligibility reconciliation are outstanding."},"career":{"complete":false,"note":"Dated parliamentary profile roles and attributed prior employment; unknown dates remain unknown."},"interests":{"period":"1 February–30 June 2026","complete":false},"donations":{"complete":false,"note":"Not reconciled"},"research_cutoff":"2026-11-18"},"summary":"Identity checked against the pilot sources. The corrected dossier awaits owner review.","owner_accepted":false},{"id":"LC-PURCELL","slug":"georgie-purcell","name":"Georgie Purcell","party":"Animal Justice Party","chamber":"Legislative Council","electorate":"Northern Victoria","jurisdiction":"Victoria","profile_url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/members/georgie-purcell/","snapshot_date":"2026-11-18","electoral_status":"Outgoing 60th Parliament member; 2026 candidacy separately checked at pilot cutoff","published":0,"watched":1,"last_checked":"2026-11-19T02:00:20+00:00","next_check":"2026-11-20T02:00:20+00:00","coverage":{"votes":{"complete":false,"note":"Pilot division sample only. Full historical backfill and eligibility reconciliation are outstanding."},"career":{"complete":false,"note":"Dated parliamentary profile roles and attributed prior employment; unknown dates remain unknown."},"interests":{"period":"1 February–30 June 2026","complete":false},"donations":{"complete":false,"note":"Not reconciled"},"research_cutoff":"2026-11-18"},"summary":"Identity checked against the pilot sources. The corrected dossier awaits owner review.","owner_accepted":false},{"id":"LC-PAYNE","slug":"rachel-payne","name":"Rachel Payne","party":"Legalise Cannabis Victoria","chamber":"Legislative Council","electorate":"South-Eastern Metropolitan","jurisdiction":"Victoria","profile_url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/members/rachel-payne/","snapshot_date":"2026-11-18","electoral_status":"Outgoing 60th Parliament member; 2026 candidacy separately checked at pilot cutoff","published":0,"watched":1,"last_checked":"2026-11-19T02:01:08+00:00","next_check":"2026-11-20T02:01:08+00:00","coverage":{"votes":{"complete":false,"note":"Pilot division sample only. Full historical backfill and eligibility reconciliation are outstanding."},"career":{"complete":false,"note":"Dated parliamentary profile roles and attributed prior employment; unknown dates remain unknown."},"interests":{"period":"1 February–30 June 2026","complete":false},"donations":{"complete":false,"note":"Not reconciled"},"research_cutoff":"2026-11-18"},"summary":"Identity checked against the pilot sources. The corrected dossier awaits owner review.","owner_accepted":false}],"evidence":[{"id":"LA-CARROLL-R01","person_id":"LA-CARROLL","title":"Carroll's dated official roles distinguish his Niddrie service, Premier appointment, Education term and different Roads and Public Transport end ","detail":"Carroll's dated official roles distinguish his Niddrie service, Premier appointment, Education term and different Roads and Public Transport end dates.","kind":"statement","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"supported_as_official_record","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0195-L0217","url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/members/ben-carroll/","source_id":"profile-carrol","text_sha256":"14cd0adea23fc3fc483b901daf151d115b1dd565413afe508d43bc895d1d871e"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff and the inspected source set; responsibility must be assessed against Carroll's dated offices.","The VCAA review, appointments and government acceptance of recommendations are documented. His prior knowledge and response to warnings, fairness of all affected student outcomes, full implementation and the evidential basis for assurances remain unresolved. The claim that he dismissed the entire board is not established.","The teacher-workforce figures are attributable to Carroll but numerically unverified. Registered teachers, employed teachers, vacancies and forecasts are different measures. The supplementary exchange supplied no requested number of schools cancelling classes; the Speaker's relevance ruling does not establish a complete numerical answer or factual accuracy. Knowing deception is not established.","Carroll's introduction of the IBAC bill and its subsequent assent are verified. Sole authorship, delivery of each promise, final legal scope, commencement and practical effectiveness remain separate checks.","Declared property, hospitality and family connections establish disclosed relationships, not an improper decision or comprehensive compliance. Donations, other reporting periods, relevant decisions and any conflict-management or recusal evidence remain open.","Operation Harmonia expressly excludes Carroll from adverse comment and finds that departmental advice misled him. It does not support a personal cover-up finding in that matter or establish a lifetime clearance.","The retained evidence does not currently establish personal corruption or knowing dishonesty. Acceptance of the qualified dossier does not resolve its open claims or approve publication, scoring or building."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-CARROLL-R02","person_id":"LA-CARROLL","title":"Carroll's February-June 2026 return declares the stated rental income, residential land, professional and union memberships, family employment co","detail":"Carroll's February-June 2026 return declares the stated rental income, residential land, professional and union memberships, family employment connections and gifts, subject to the form's scope.","kind":"disclosure","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"supported_as_self_declaration","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0001-L0035, L0102-L0123, L0186-L0271, L0277-L0299","url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/4a4bd8/globalassets/tabled-paper-documents/tabled-paper-10411/ordinary-returns-submitted-by-members-of-the-legislative-assembly-vol-1-of-2---1-february-2026-to-30-june-2026.pdf","source_id":"interests-assembly-2026-1","text_sha256":"9016680bbd6e80356def6e41b1aa7af365050d05c6ce11084454989a980685f2"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff and the inspected source set; responsibility must be assessed against Carroll's dated offices.","The VCAA review, appointments and government acceptance of recommendations are documented. His prior knowledge and response to warnings, fairness of all affected student outcomes, full implementation and the evidential basis for assurances remain unresolved. The claim that he dismissed the entire board is not established.","The teacher-workforce figures are attributable to Carroll but numerically unverified. Registered teachers, employed teachers, vacancies and forecasts are different measures. The supplementary exchange supplied no requested number of schools cancelling classes; the Speaker's relevance ruling does not establish a complete numerical answer or factual accuracy. Knowing deception is not established.","Carroll's introduction of the IBAC bill and its subsequent assent are verified. Sole authorship, delivery of each promise, final legal scope, commencement and practical effectiveness remain separate checks.","Declared property, hospitality and family connections establish disclosed relationships, not an improper decision or comprehensive compliance. Donations, other reporting periods, relevant decisions and any conflict-management or recusal evidence remain open.","Operation Harmonia expressly excludes Carroll from adverse comment and finds that departmental advice misled him. It does not support a personal cover-up finding in that matter or establish a lifetime clearance.","The retained evidence does not currently establish personal corruption or knowing dishonesty. Acceptance of the qualified dossier does not resolve its open claims or approve publication, scoring or building."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-CARROLL-R03","person_id":"LA-CARROLL","title":"The November VCE statement commits to grade checking, independent oversight and a January review; the December announcement names the reviewer an","detail":"The November VCE statement commits to grade checking, independent oversight and a January review; the December announcement names the reviewer and monitor.","kind":"statement","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"supported_announcements","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0003-L0037","url":"https://www.premier.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/2024-11/241118-Ensuring-Fairness-In-The-Marking-Of-2024-VCE-Exams.pdf","source_id":"carroll-vce-promise","text_sha256":"57b2da4fb34aea5d99afd0e130fd2574eb26c424ee41193b22b25fb06b5503f8"},{"lines":"L0001-L0029","url":"https://www.premier.vic.gov.au/vcaa-root-and-branch-reviewer-and-monitor-appointed","source_id":"carroll-monitor","text_sha256":"f9c2c0838a16367ac150e6fbaee192e86ecb4f3c524f3a6d18f7e27b1e0321fb"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff and the inspected source set; responsibility must be assessed against Carroll's dated offices.","The VCAA review, appointments and government acceptance of recommendations are documented. His prior knowledge and response to warnings, fairness of all affected student outcomes, full implementation and the evidential basis for assurances remain unresolved. The claim that he dismissed the entire board is not established.","The teacher-workforce figures are attributable to Carroll but numerically unverified. Registered teachers, employed teachers, vacancies and forecasts are different measures. The supplementary exchange supplied no requested number of schools cancelling classes; the Speaker's relevance ruling does not establish a complete numerical answer or factual accuracy. Knowing deception is not established.","Carroll's introduction of the IBAC bill and its subsequent assent are verified. Sole authorship, delivery of each promise, final legal scope, commencement and practical effectiveness remain separate checks.","Declared property, hospitality and family connections establish disclosed relationships, not an improper decision or comprehensive compliance. Donations, other reporting periods, relevant decisions and any conflict-management or recusal evidence remain open.","Operation Harmonia expressly excludes Carroll from adverse comment and finds that departmental advice misled him. It does not support a personal cover-up finding in that matter or establish a lifetime clearance.","The retained evidence does not currently establish personal corruption or knowing dishonesty. Acceptance of the qualified dossier does not resolve its open claims or approve publication, scoring or building."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-CARROLL-R04","person_id":"LA-CARROLL","title":"The government's VCAA page records eight Stage One and eleven Stage Two recommendations, all accepted, without proving full implementation or eve","detail":"The government's VCAA page records eight Stage One and eleven Stage Two recommendations, all accepted, without proving full implementation or every affected student's outcome.","kind":"statement","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"supported_with_outcome_limit","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0004-L0047","url":"https://www.vic.gov.au/blacher-review-vcaa","source_id":"vcaa-blacher-reports","text_sha256":"5d333c4fa6c7cf591e07e9d19644534d3c2a5d77dd150dc8fe7638dd19c95974"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff and the inspected source set; responsibility must be assessed against Carroll's dated offices.","The VCAA review, appointments and government acceptance of recommendations are documented. His prior knowledge and response to warnings, fairness of all affected student outcomes, full implementation and the evidential basis for assurances remain unresolved. The claim that he dismissed the entire board is not established.","The teacher-workforce figures are attributable to Carroll but numerically unverified. Registered teachers, employed teachers, vacancies and forecasts are different measures. The supplementary exchange supplied no requested number of schools cancelling classes; the Speaker's relevance ruling does not establish a complete numerical answer or factual accuracy. Knowing deception is not established.","Carroll's introduction of the IBAC bill and its subsequent assent are verified. Sole authorship, delivery of each promise, final legal scope, commencement and practical effectiveness remain separate checks.","Declared property, hospitality and family connections establish disclosed relationships, not an improper decision or comprehensive compliance. Donations, other reporting periods, relevant decisions and any conflict-management or recusal evidence remain open.","Operation Harmonia expressly excludes Carroll from adverse comment and finds that departmental advice misled him. It does not support a personal cover-up finding in that matter or establish a lifetime clearance.","The retained evidence does not currently establish personal corruption or knowing dishonesty. Acceptance of the qualified dossier does not resolve its open claims or approve publication, scoring or building."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-CARROLL-R05","person_id":"LA-CARROLL","title":"Carroll made the specified teacher-workforce numerical claims in the 21 March 2024 exchange, but this Hansard record does not independently verif","detail":"Carroll made the specified teacher-workforce numerical claims in the 21 March 2024 exchange, but this Hansard record does not independently verify them.","kind":"statement","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"attributed_only_numerical_truth_unresolved","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0253-L0299","url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/parliamentary-activity/hansard/hansard-details/HANSARD-2145855009-25304","source_id":"teacher-workforce-debate","text_sha256":"2fc6a853b7ce580f67bad595c457aa1191254a66afd14ecccbcdfa631db1efd3"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff and the inspected source set; responsibility must be assessed against Carroll's dated offices.","The VCAA review, appointments and government acceptance of recommendations are documented. His prior knowledge and response to warnings, fairness of all affected student outcomes, full implementation and the evidential basis for assurances remain unresolved. The claim that he dismissed the entire board is not established.","The teacher-workforce figures are attributable to Carroll but numerically unverified. Registered teachers, employed teachers, vacancies and forecasts are different measures. The supplementary exchange supplied no requested number of schools cancelling classes; the Speaker's relevance ruling does not establish a complete numerical answer or factual accuracy. Knowing deception is not established.","Carroll's introduction of the IBAC bill and its subsequent assent are verified. Sole authorship, delivery of each promise, final legal scope, commencement and practical effectiveness remain separate checks.","Declared property, hospitality and family connections establish disclosed relationships, not an improper decision or comprehensive compliance. Donations, other reporting periods, relevant decisions and any conflict-management or recusal evidence remain open.","Operation Harmonia expressly excludes Carroll from adverse comment and finds that departmental advice misled him. It does not support a personal cover-up finding in that matter or establish a lifetime clearance.","The retained evidence does not currently establish personal corruption or knowing dishonesty. Acceptance of the qualified dossier does not resolve its open claims or approve publication, scoring or building."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-CARROLL-R06","person_id":"LA-CARROLL","title":"The official IBAC amendment bill history records introduction by Carroll on 8 September 2026, Council amendments and assent on 1 October 2026.","detail":"The official IBAC amendment bill history records introduction by Carroll on 8 September 2026, Council amendments and assent on 1 October 2026.","kind":"statement","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"supported_procedural_outcome","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0001-L0199","url":"https://www.legislation.vic.gov.au/bills/independent-broad-based-anti-corruption-commission-amendment-bill-2026","source_id":"ibac-amendment-bill-status","text_sha256":"a989b55ad98a789cbfd5c2d117761a0e18e373df8aa67ece70b29f2061376578"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff and the inspected source set; responsibility must be assessed against Carroll's dated offices.","The VCAA review, appointments and government acceptance of recommendations are documented. His prior knowledge and response to warnings, fairness of all affected student outcomes, full implementation and the evidential basis for assurances remain unresolved. The claim that he dismissed the entire board is not established.","The teacher-workforce figures are attributable to Carroll but numerically unverified. Registered teachers, employed teachers, vacancies and forecasts are different measures. The supplementary exchange supplied no requested number of schools cancelling classes; the Speaker's relevance ruling does not establish a complete numerical answer or factual accuracy. Knowing deception is not established.","Carroll's introduction of the IBAC bill and its subsequent assent are verified. Sole authorship, delivery of each promise, final legal scope, commencement and practical effectiveness remain separate checks.","Declared property, hospitality and family connections establish disclosed relationships, not an improper decision or comprehensive compliance. Donations, other reporting periods, relevant decisions and any conflict-management or recusal evidence remain open.","Operation Harmonia expressly excludes Carroll from adverse comment and finds that departmental advice misled him. It does not support a personal cover-up finding in that matter or establish a lifetime clearance.","The retained evidence does not currently establish personal corruption or knowing dishonesty. Acceptance of the qualified dossier does not resolve its open claims or approve publication, scoring or building."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-CARROLL-R07","person_id":"LA-CARROLL","title":"Operation Harmonia explicitly excludes Carroll from adverse comment and finds departmental advice misled him about grant errors and his predecess","detail":"Operation Harmonia explicitly excludes Carroll from adverse comment and finds departmental advice misled him about grant errors and his predecessor's knowledge.","kind":"finding","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"supported_authoritative_finding_with_person_limit","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0026-L0049, L0160-L0170, L0334-L0371, L0430-L0441","url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/4a940d/globalassets/tabled-paper-documents/tabled-paper-10550/ibac_harmonia_special_report_web-updated-2.pdf","source_id":"ibac-harmonia-report","text_sha256":"afa0063f85606e97a793816816664c086783596ec413efea4b6ac5733750bd33"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff and the inspected source set; responsibility must be assessed against Carroll's dated offices.","The VCAA review, appointments and government acceptance of recommendations are documented. His prior knowledge and response to warnings, fairness of all affected student outcomes, full implementation and the evidential basis for assurances remain unresolved. The claim that he dismissed the entire board is not established.","The teacher-workforce figures are attributable to Carroll but numerically unverified. Registered teachers, employed teachers, vacancies and forecasts are different measures. The supplementary exchange supplied no requested number of schools cancelling classes; the Speaker's relevance ruling does not establish a complete numerical answer or factual accuracy. Knowing deception is not established.","Carroll's introduction of the IBAC bill and its subsequent assent are verified. Sole authorship, delivery of each promise, final legal scope, commencement and practical effectiveness remain separate checks.","Declared property, hospitality and family connections establish disclosed relationships, not an improper decision or comprehensive compliance. Donations, other reporting periods, relevant decisions and any conflict-management or recusal evidence remain open.","Operation Harmonia expressly excludes Carroll from adverse comment and finds that departmental advice misled him. It does not support a personal cover-up finding in that matter or establish a lifetime clearance.","The retained evidence does not currently establish personal corruption or knowing dishonesty. Acceptance of the qualified dossier does not resolve its open claims or approve publication, scoring or building."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-WILSON-R01","person_id":"LA-WILSON","title":"Wilson's official profile records first election for Kew in 2022, Opposition Leader from 18 November 2025 and Shadow Treasurer from 13 October 20","detail":"Wilson's official profile records first election for Kew in 2022, Opposition Leader from 18 November 2025 and Shadow Treasurer from 13 October 2025, with earlier dated shadow roles.","kind":"statement","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"supported_as_official_record","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0116-L0139","url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/members/jess-wilson/","source_id":"profile-wilson","text_sha256":"c724d8985bcca598b749acb07138e1d501ccf8fa5e7a9fadefa1be7b9523d499"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff, dated responsibilities and inspected source set. It does not currently establish knowing dishonesty or corruption.","Wilson's teacher-workforce questions establish individual scrutiny and a request for a measurable answer. Her forecast shortage, vacancy count, incentive percentage and cancelled-class example remain unverified. Carroll's incomplete answer does not validate her premises.","Her $11,000 levy description and attributed industry predictions are verified as statements she made. Their accuracy and whether the wording was materially misleading in December 2025 require the original announcement, applicable schedule and actual industry statements. The later indexed $11,350 amount does not retrospectively disprove her earlier figure; economic incidence and supply effects remain unresolved. The unsupported modelling-estimate description is removed.","Financial and family connections are signed self-declarations for February-June 2026, not a full audit or proof of an improper decision. Payments received by the trust must remain separate from direct personal receipts. Other reporting periods, donations and relevant conflict-management records remain open.","Her 1 April 2026 aye was on introducing the rent-control bill; it establishes neither support for every provision nor motive, enactment or a commitment to impose rent controls. The proposer's two-year freeze and subsequent wage-linked cap were proposed changes. Detailed coverage and exceptions require the bill itself; the defeated introduction motion enacted no rent controls.","The unsupported coercive-control achievement and causal account was removed from the research; that correction does not establish that Wilson falsely claimed credit. Its official legislative record remains a research gap.","The bounded formal-record searches establish no adverse personal finding in the retained evidence, without supplying a comprehensive court, privileges, IBAC or Ombudsman history or lifetime clearance."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-WILSON-R02","person_id":"LA-WILSON","title":"Wilson's February-June 2026 signed return identifies personal trust income, a company shareholding, separate trust-received payments, residential","detail":"Wilson's February-June 2026 signed return identifies personal trust income, a company shareholding, separate trust-received payments, residential and family interests, memberships and gifts.","kind":"disclosure","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"supported_as_self_declaration","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0001-L0067, L0111-L0199, L0206-L0280","url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/4a4bdb/globalassets/tabled-paper-documents/tabled-paper-10411/ordinary-returns-submitted-by-members-of-the-legislative-assembly-vol-2-of-2---1-february-2026-to-30-june-2026.pdf","source_id":"interests-assembly-2026-2","text_sha256":"8067b167b498c481cf0435b3b4cba1ced4c274f7776a09a05117b286be57b21c"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff, dated responsibilities and inspected source set. It does not currently establish knowing dishonesty or corruption.","Wilson's teacher-workforce questions establish individual scrutiny and a request for a measurable answer. Her forecast shortage, vacancy count, incentive percentage and cancelled-class example remain unverified. Carroll's incomplete answer does not validate her premises.","Her $11,000 levy description and attributed industry predictions are verified as statements she made. Their accuracy and whether the wording was materially misleading in December 2025 require the original announcement, applicable schedule and actual industry statements. The later indexed $11,350 amount does not retrospectively disprove her earlier figure; economic incidence and supply effects remain unresolved. The unsupported modelling-estimate description is removed.","Financial and family connections are signed self-declarations for February-June 2026, not a full audit or proof of an improper decision. Payments received by the trust must remain separate from direct personal receipts. Other reporting periods, donations and relevant conflict-management records remain open.","Her 1 April 2026 aye was on introducing the rent-control bill; it establishes neither support for every provision nor motive, enactment or a commitment to impose rent controls. The proposer's two-year freeze and subsequent wage-linked cap were proposed changes. Detailed coverage and exceptions require the bill itself; the defeated introduction motion enacted no rent controls.","The unsupported coercive-control achievement and causal account was removed from the research; that correction does not establish that Wilson falsely claimed credit. Its official legislative record remains a research gap.","The bounded formal-record searches establish no adverse personal finding in the retained evidence, without supplying a comprehensive court, privileges, IBAC or Ombudsman history or lifetime clearance."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-WILSON-R03","person_id":"LA-WILSON","title":"Wilson made the specified projected-shortage, vacancy and incentive assertions on 21 March 2024, and asked about cancelled classes; Carroll respo","detail":"Wilson made the specified projected-shortage, vacancy and incentive assertions on 21 March 2024, and asked about cancelled classes; Carroll responded with different workforce measures.","kind":"statement","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"attributed_only_numerical_truth_unresolved","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0253-L0299","url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/parliamentary-activity/hansard/hansard-details/HANSARD-2145855009-25304","source_id":"teacher-workforce-debate","text_sha256":"2fc6a853b7ce580f67bad595c457aa1191254a66afd14ecccbcdfa631db1efd3"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff, dated responsibilities and inspected source set. It does not currently establish knowing dishonesty or corruption.","Wilson's teacher-workforce questions establish individual scrutiny and a request for a measurable answer. Her forecast shortage, vacancy count, incentive percentage and cancelled-class example remain unverified. Carroll's incomplete answer does not validate her premises.","Her $11,000 levy description and attributed industry predictions are verified as statements she made. Their accuracy and whether the wording was materially misleading in December 2025 require the original announcement, applicable schedule and actual industry statements. The later indexed $11,350 amount does not retrospectively disprove her earlier figure; economic incidence and supply effects remain unresolved. The unsupported modelling-estimate description is removed.","Financial and family connections are signed self-declarations for February-June 2026, not a full audit or proof of an improper decision. Payments received by the trust must remain separate from direct personal receipts. Other reporting periods, donations and relevant conflict-management records remain open.","Her 1 April 2026 aye was on introducing the rent-control bill; it establishes neither support for every provision nor motive, enactment or a commitment to impose rent controls. The proposer's two-year freeze and subsequent wage-linked cap were proposed changes. Detailed coverage and exceptions require the bill itself; the defeated introduction motion enacted no rent controls.","The unsupported coercive-control achievement and causal account was removed from the research; that correction does not establish that Wilson falsely claimed credit. Its official legislative record remains a research gap.","The bounded formal-record searches establish no adverse personal finding in the retained evidence, without supplying a comprehensive court, privileges, IBAC or Ombudsman history or lifetime clearance."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-WILSON-R04","person_id":"LA-WILSON","title":"Wilson described an $11,000 infrastructure contribution as a tax on home ownership and attributed a predicted supply reduction to industry bodies","detail":"Wilson described an $11,000 infrastructure contribution as a tax on home ownership and attributed a predicted supply reduction to industry bodies; Allan defended the policy.","kind":"statement","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"supported_as_attributed_exchange","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0276-L0336","url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/parliamentary-activity/hansard/hansard-details/HANSARD-2145855009-33773","source_id":"wilson-housing-claim","text_sha256":"f89a768c75a038181c3a767208bf36631a272030d7a0e940f063cf51a22038f1"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff, dated responsibilities and inspected source set. It does not currently establish knowing dishonesty or corruption.","Wilson's teacher-workforce questions establish individual scrutiny and a request for a measurable answer. Her forecast shortage, vacancy count, incentive percentage and cancelled-class example remain unverified. Carroll's incomplete answer does not validate her premises.","Her $11,000 levy description and attributed industry predictions are verified as statements she made. Their accuracy and whether the wording was materially misleading in December 2025 require the original announcement, applicable schedule and actual industry statements. The later indexed $11,350 amount does not retrospectively disprove her earlier figure; economic incidence and supply effects remain unresolved. The unsupported modelling-estimate description is removed.","Financial and family connections are signed self-declarations for February-June 2026, not a full audit or proof of an improper decision. Payments received by the trust must remain separate from direct personal receipts. Other reporting periods, donations and relevant conflict-management records remain open.","Her 1 April 2026 aye was on introducing the rent-control bill; it establishes neither support for every provision nor motive, enactment or a commitment to impose rent controls. The proposer's two-year freeze and subsequent wage-linked cap were proposed changes. Detailed coverage and exceptions require the bill itself; the defeated introduction motion enacted no rent controls.","The unsupported coercive-control achievement and causal account was removed from the research; that correction does not establish that Wilson falsely claimed credit. Its official legislative record remains a research gap.","The bounded formal-record searches establish no adverse personal finding in the retained evidence, without supplying a comprehensive court, privileges, IBAC or Ombudsman history or lifetime clearance."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-WILSON-R05","person_id":"LA-WILSON","title":"The later official infrastructure guide describes collection in specified areas from 2027 and a 2026-27 residential standard rate of $11,350 per ","detail":"The later official infrastructure guide describes collection in specified areas from 2027 and a 2026-27 residential standard rate of $11,350 per additional dwelling or lot, without resolving the exact 2025 announcement or economic effects.","kind":"statement","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"primary_context_verified_exact_historical_claim_unresolved","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0001-L0005","url":"https://www.planning.vic.gov.au/guides-and-resources/legislation-regulation-and-fees/infrastructure-contributions","source_id":"housing-levies-web-check","text_sha256":"3d33ee14eaf266ed67bf14a94781bad23f4ffa92cba8560a436926b8341a9047"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff, dated responsibilities and inspected source set. It does not currently establish knowing dishonesty or corruption.","Wilson's teacher-workforce questions establish individual scrutiny and a request for a measurable answer. Her forecast shortage, vacancy count, incentive percentage and cancelled-class example remain unverified. Carroll's incomplete answer does not validate her premises.","Her $11,000 levy description and attributed industry predictions are verified as statements she made. Their accuracy and whether the wording was materially misleading in December 2025 require the original announcement, applicable schedule and actual industry statements. The later indexed $11,350 amount does not retrospectively disprove her earlier figure; economic incidence and supply effects remain unresolved. The unsupported modelling-estimate description is removed.","Financial and family connections are signed self-declarations for February-June 2026, not a full audit or proof of an improper decision. Payments received by the trust must remain separate from direct personal receipts. Other reporting periods, donations and relevant conflict-management records remain open.","Her 1 April 2026 aye was on introducing the rent-control bill; it establishes neither support for every provision nor motive, enactment or a commitment to impose rent controls. The proposer's two-year freeze and subsequent wage-linked cap were proposed changes. Detailed coverage and exceptions require the bill itself; the defeated introduction motion enacted no rent controls.","The unsupported coercive-control achievement and causal account was removed from the research; that correction does not establish that Wilson falsely claimed credit. Its official legislative record remains a research gap.","The bounded formal-record searches establish no adverse personal finding in the retained evidence, without supplying a comprehensive court, privileges, IBAC or Ombudsman history or lifetime clearance."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-WILSON-R06","person_id":"LA-WILSON","title":"Wilson is named among the ayes on the 1 April 2026 motion to introduce the rent control bill, which was defeated 31-48.","detail":"Wilson is named among the ayes on the 1 April 2026 motion to introduce the rent control bill, which was defeated 31-48.","kind":"action","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"supported_procedural_action","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0308-L0313, L0524-L0545","url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/parliamentary-activity/hansard/hansard-details/HANSARD-2145855009-35166","source_id":"sandell-rent-bill","text_sha256":"cedc5092b4a107fdb9976f82226c99ddf04e84bfc8ac5ba14dc230997cff62f6"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff, dated responsibilities and inspected source set. It does not currently establish knowing dishonesty or corruption.","Wilson's teacher-workforce questions establish individual scrutiny and a request for a measurable answer. Her forecast shortage, vacancy count, incentive percentage and cancelled-class example remain unverified. Carroll's incomplete answer does not validate her premises.","Her $11,000 levy description and attributed industry predictions are verified as statements she made. Their accuracy and whether the wording was materially misleading in December 2025 require the original announcement, applicable schedule and actual industry statements. The later indexed $11,350 amount does not retrospectively disprove her earlier figure; economic incidence and supply effects remain unresolved. The unsupported modelling-estimate description is removed.","Financial and family connections are signed self-declarations for February-June 2026, not a full audit or proof of an improper decision. Payments received by the trust must remain separate from direct personal receipts. Other reporting periods, donations and relevant conflict-management records remain open.","Her 1 April 2026 aye was on introducing the rent-control bill; it establishes neither support for every provision nor motive, enactment or a commitment to impose rent controls. The proposer's two-year freeze and subsequent wage-linked cap were proposed changes. Detailed coverage and exceptions require the bill itself; the defeated introduction motion enacted no rent controls.","The unsupported coercive-control achievement and causal account was removed from the research; that correction does not establish that Wilson falsely claimed credit. Its official legislative record remains a research gap.","The bounded formal-record searches establish no adverse personal finding in the retained evidence, without supplying a comprehensive court, privileges, IBAC or Ombudsman history or lifetime clearance."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"},{"id":"LA-WILSON-R07","person_id":"LA-WILSON","title":"After Parliament's expiry on 3 November 2026, the VEC list separately confirms Wilson's Liberal candidacy for Kew for the 28 November election.","detail":"After Parliament's expiry on 3 November 2026, the VEC list separately confirms Wilson's Liberal candidacy for Kew for the 28 November election.","kind":"statement","event_date":null,"date_precision":"unknown","status":"published","finding_status":"supported_dated_status","source_refs":[{"lines":"L0001-L0039","url":"https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/election","source_id":"election-status","text_sha256":"ee4ddcbaac235e2812c44d1cdf5913b3be5bda3a26ddb3ab6348c9362e3e7b94"},{"lines":"L0127-L0138","url":"https://www.vec.vic.gov.au/-/media/958b669c22504a06b0c5af2e4d461a3d.pdf","source_id":"vec-nominations","text_sha256":"23075addb99a64fe638a3f8346c88b737160c3b0ca031e9e011267a01af8a985"}],"qualifications":["The account is bounded by the 18 November 2026 cutoff, dated responsibilities and inspected source set. It does not currently establish knowing dishonesty or corruption.","Wilson's teacher-workforce questions establish individual scrutiny and a request for a measurable answer. Her forecast shortage, vacancy count, incentive percentage and cancelled-class example remain unverified. Carroll's incomplete answer does not validate her premises.","Her $11,000 levy description and attributed industry predictions are verified as statements she made. Their accuracy and whether the wording was materially misleading in December 2025 require the original announcement, applicable schedule and actual industry statements. The later indexed $11,350 amount does not retrospectively disprove her earlier figure; economic incidence and supply effects remain unresolved. The unsupported modelling-estimate description is removed.","Financial and family connections are signed self-declarations for February-June 2026, not a full audit or proof of an improper decision. Payments received by the trust must remain separate from direct personal receipts. Other reporting periods, donations and relevant conflict-management records remain open.","Her 1 April 2026 aye was on introducing the rent-control bill; it establishes neither support for every provision nor motive, enactment or a commitment to impose rent controls. The proposer's two-year freeze and subsequent wage-linked cap were proposed changes. Detailed coverage and exceptions require the bill itself; the defeated introduction motion enacted no rent controls.","The unsupported coercive-control achievement and causal account was removed from the research; that correction does not establish that Wilson falsely claimed credit. Its official legislative record remains a research gap.","The bounded formal-record searches establish no adverse personal finding in the retained evidence, without supplying a comprehensive court, privileges, IBAC or Ombudsman history or lifetime clearance."],"response":"","origin":"Independently corrected Greenshift GPU pilot","created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","reviewed_by":"Owner with recorded qualifications"}],"policies":[{"id":"education","name":"Education and workforce","description":"Schools, teacher supply and examination safeguards","criterion":"What individual decisions, claims or scrutiny concern school staffing and examination fairness? Distinguish registered teachers, employment, vacancies and forecasts.","active":1,"revision":1,"created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","updated_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00"},{"id":"environment","name":"Environment and animal welfare","description":"Environmental protection and animal welfare decisions","criterion":"What individually recorded positions and actions concern environmental protection or animal welfare? Distinguish campaigning, committee work and policy delivery.","active":1,"revision":1,"created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","updated_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00"},{"id":"health","name":"Health and ambulance services","description":"Service delivery, data quality and oversight","criterion":"What individual actions and claims concern health service delivery and ambulance oversight? Preserve responses, contrary evidence and unresolved outcomes.","active":1,"revision":1,"created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","updated_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00"},{"id":"housing","name":"Housing and renting","description":"Rental affordability, rent controls and housing supply","criterion":"What has this politician personally said or done about rental affordability, rent controls and housing supply? Distinguish proposals, procedural votes, enacted changes and measured outcomes.","active":1,"revision":1,"created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","updated_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00"},{"id":"integrity","name":"Integrity and accountability","description":"Oversight powers, scrutiny and documented findings","criterion":"What individual actions concern oversight and accountability? Keep authoritative findings, allegations, responses and procedural votes separate; never infer dishonesty or corruption from a connection.","active":1,"revision":1,"created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","updated_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00"},{"id":"drug-policy","name":"Medicinal cannabis and road policy","description":"Cannabis law reform and driving evidence","criterion":"What individual actions and claims concern medicinal cannabis and driving policy? Distinguish passage, commencement, trial milestones, individual authorship and outcomes.","active":1,"revision":1,"created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","updated_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00"},{"id":"spending","name":"Public spending and infrastructure","description":"Public expenditure, infrastructure and counterfactual cost claims","criterion":"What individually attributable statements or decisions concern public spending and infrastructure? Separate audited totals, estimates and unverified counterfactuals.","active":1,"revision":1,"created_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00","updated_at":"2026-11-19T01:53:02+00:00"}],"complete_voting_history":false}